Judge weighs Alex Murdaugh's bid to dismiss murder charges before 2027 retrial
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
A South Carolina judge heard arguments Friday on Alex Murdaugh's motion to dismiss his murder indictments.
The ruling decides whether the retrial set for April 5, 2027, proceeds on the current charges.
Background
Alex Murdaugh is a disgraced former South Carolina lawyer, 58, convicted in 2023 of killing his wife Maggie and son Paul, then sentenced to life without parole. The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned those convictions in May 2026, ruling that Colleton County Clerk of Court Rebecca "Becky" Hill improperly influenced jurors, and ordered a new trial. Murdaugh, who has admitted being a thief, insurance cheat and longtime opioid addict but denies being a killer, is also serving decades in prison for stealing millions from clients. His defense now argues the case's chief investigator lied to the grand jury, and the pretrial fight is over whether the murder charges survive to the retrial.
How it unfolded
- Jun 7, 2021Murdaugh called 911 reporting that his wife Maggie and son Paul had been shot; prosecutors say he killed them on their property in the South Carolina Lowcountry.
- 2023A jury convicted Murdaugh of two counts of murder, and he was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
- 2024State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) agent David Owen abruptly retired, not long after being honored as State Law Enforcement Officer of the Year.
- May 13, 2026The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned Murdaugh's double murder convictions and life sentence, ruling that clerk of court Becky Hill improperly influenced jurors, and ordered a new trial.
- Jun 29, 2026Judge Debra R. McCaslin set a tentative retrial date of April 5, 2027.
- Aug 5, 2026A federal judge dismissed Murdaugh's civil lawsuit against former court clerk Becky Hill without prejudice.
- Aug 10, 2026Murdaugh's defense team filed a motion to dismiss all four pending criminal indictments — two murder charges and two related weapons charges — over alleged "false" and "fabricated" evidence.
- Aug 30, 2026The defense filed a 33-page memorandum in support of the motion, with more than a hundred pages of exhibits.
- Nov 6, 2026Prosecutors from South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson's office filed their formal response to the motion by this date.
- Nov 10, 2026Murdaugh's defense team responded to the state's opposition to his request to dismiss the murder indictments.
- Nov 13, 2026A pretrial hearing was held at 10 a.m. at the Lexington County Courthouse before Judge Debra McCaslin on the defense motion to dismiss.
- Nov 13, 2026At the hearing, McCaslin said she had reviewed the personnel files of some SLED agents under seal and found no information that needed to be released to the defense.
- Nov 13, 2026McCaslin said she plans to hold the next hearing Jan. 20 in Sumter, when she hopes to send out a questionnaire to potential jurors.
Key terms
- indictments
- A formal accusation that a person has committed a crime, typically issued by a grand jury.
- grand jury
- A jury empowered by law to investigate potential crimes and decide whether criminal charges should be brought.
- without prejudice
- A dismissal that does not bar the claim from being brought again in a later lawsuit.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Defense
- Lawyers Dick Harpootlian and Jim Griffin say chief investigator David Owen lied to the grand jury — about blood spatter on a T-shirt and about matching ammunition found across the property — and that the state fabricated and misrepresented evidence.
- Prosecution
- Prosecutors led by Creighton Waters strongly deny presenting false evidence, write that "a single mistake is not bad faith," and say plenty of other evidence supports the murder charges.
- Analysts
- Legal analyst Jessica Levinson notes that even if the judge finds the chief investigator lied, much of the evidence in the case does not relate to him; media attorney Jay Bender calls a motion to dismiss at this stage "dramatic."
Still unverified
CNN reporter Dianne Gallagher said Judge McCaslin could require new murder indictments to be issued, but cautioned that outcome was not a certainty; the defense's allegations of fabricated evidence and perjured testimony are disputed by prosecutors, who deny deliberate misconduct.