Misquote by Supreme Court justice threatens gun limits
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
A New York Times review found courts used Scalia's "dangerous and unusual" test in at least 98 gun cases since 2008.
The Supreme Court hears a challenge to Illinois and Connecticut assault-weapons bans in December 2026.
Background
Justice Antonin Scalia wrote the 2008 majority opinion in District of Columbia v. Heller, which first declared the Second Amendment guaranteed an individual's right to possess a gun apart from militia service. In it he attributed the phrase "dangerous and unusual" to Sir William Blackstone, the 18th-century English jurist whose writings underpin much of American law — but Blackstone's treatise actually said "dangerous or unusual." A New York Times review found courts have applied the "dangerous and unusual" test in at least 98 civil cases challenging weapons restrictions since Heller, and the wording is now central as the Supreme Court prepares to hear a challenge to assault-weapons bans in Illinois and Connecticut.
How it unfolded
- 1769Sir William Blackstone's "Commentaries on the Laws of England" referred to weapons that were "dangerous or unusual."
- 2008Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the majority in District of Columbia v. Heller, attributed the "dangerous and unusual" language to Blackstone and declared the Second Amendment guaranteed an individual right to possess a gun.
- 2022The Supreme Court's ruling in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen folded the "dangerous and unusual" standard into a new process for judging firearms restrictions.
- 2023Federal judge Roger Benitez in California noted the test's wording when he struck down the state's ban on assault weapons.
- 2025A federal appeals court upheld Connecticut's assault-weapons ban, citing a tradition of restricting "unusually dangerous" weapons and explicitly rejecting the "dangerous and unusual" test from Heller.
- Dec 2, 2026The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments in a case challenging assault-weapons bans in Illinois and Connecticut.
Key terms
- Heller
- A landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision holding that the Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear arms for lawful purposes like self-defense.
- assault-weapons
- A controversial U.S. term for various firearms, often semi-automatic ones with detachable magazines and features like pistol grips, with no consistent definition.
- assault-weapons bans
- Laws prohibiting the manufacture or sale of certain semi-automatic firearms classified as assault weapons.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Support
- Judge Roger Benitez wrote that the court assumes the Supreme Court "does not use language frivolously, that it says what it means and it means what it says."
- Caution
- The federal appeals court that upheld Connecticut's ban said it would be "a serious subversion of our commitment to history to enshrine a conjunctive test based on the Heller opinion's possible misquote of Blackstone."
- Expert
- Second Amendment scholar Saul Cornell said the best translation of Blackstone's terminology would treat "dangerous and unusual" as a synonym for unusually dangerous.
- Bulls
- Gun-rights proponents argued in at least 14 briefs that there are more AR-15-type weapons in circulation than Ford F-series trucks, so the guns are dangerous but not unusual.
Still unverified
It is unclear whether Justice Scalia realized he was misquoting Blackstone, or whether he simply did not regard "and" versus "or" as an important distinction; half of the dozen sources he cited for the quote, including Blackstone, had used "dangerous or unusual."