NY sues T-Mobile over low-income internet data cap
arstechnica.com

NY sues T-Mobile over low-income internet data cap

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

New York settled with T-Mobile, which must drop data caps on $15 low-income plans within 120 days.
The deal enforces the state's Affordable Broadband Act for households on Medicaid or SNAP.

Background

New York's Affordable Broadband Act, passed in 2021, requires home internet providers with at least 20,000 customers to offer low-income households plans at set prices and minimum speeds — $15/month for at least 25 Mbps or $20/month for at least 200 Mbps, taxes and equipment fees included. Industry groups led by the New York State Telecommunications Association sued to block it, but after a federal appeals court sided with the state and the Supreme Court declined to hear the case in December 2024, New York began enforcing the law in January 2025. T-Mobile USA, Inc. is the telecom provider that offered the low-income plans at issue; the enforcement action stemmed from a referral by the New York State Public Service Commission.

How it unfolded

  1. 2021New York passes the Affordable Broadband Act as part of the state budget, requiring $15/month broadband for low-income households and capping 200 Mbps plans at $20 monthly.
  2. 2021A federal judge blocks implementation after broadband industry groups led by the New York State Telecommunications Association sue, alleging illegal rate regulation.
  3. Apr 2024A federal appeals court rejects the industry groups' argument and allows the state to require low-income plans going forward.
  4. Dec 20, 2024The Supreme Court declines to hear the case, leaving New York's low-income internet law standing.
  5. Jan 2025New York starts enforcing the $15 broadband law.
  6. Nov 9, 2026Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James announce a settlement with T-Mobile resolving an investigation that found the company violated the law.
  7. Nov 10, 2026Reports detail the agreement: T-Mobile must remove data caps, deliver 25 Mbps except during network congestion, offer the plans wherever it sells home internet, and make its plan webpage searchable.
  8. Within 120 daysT-Mobile must eliminate the speed limits and expand availability of the low-income plans.

Key terms

data caps
A limit set by an internet provider on how much data a customer can transfer, with extra fees beyond it.
Medicaid
A US government health insurance program for people with limited income and resources, funded jointly by states and the federal government.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Official
Attorney General Letitia James said T-Mobile flouted a law designed to help vulnerable New Yorkers and that her office is committed to ensuring they are not denied affordable home internet.
Official
Governor Kathy Hochul called the internet a lifeline for work, school and emergency services, and said the state will keep holding companies accountable.
Party
A T-Mobile spokesman said the company has a long history of low-cost broadband in New York and is updating its plan to meet state requirements at the same low price.
Caution
The settlement states T-Mobile neither admits nor denies the Attorney General's findings of non-compliance.

Still unverified

T-Mobile did not admit to any violation, stating in the settlement that it neither admits nor denies the Attorney General's findings; some reports describe the findings as allegations, including an alleged 50-gigabyte monthly data cap.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store