Democrats' Electoral College abolition plan gains traction
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
Democrats won full control in six states worth 71 electoral votes, fueling a push to join the National Popular Vote compact.
The compact needs 270 electoral votes to take effect.
Background
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is an agreement under which participating states would give all their electoral votes to the presidential ticket that wins the national popular vote. It takes effect only once states representing at least 270 electoral votes sign on. The idea gained traction after 2000, when Republican George W. Bush won the presidency while losing the national popular vote, and grew again in 2016 after Donald Trump won despite losing the popular vote. It is trending now because Democrats won full control of state government in several states in the midterms, opening a path to more sign-ons ahead of 2028.
How it unfolded
- 2000Republican George W. Bush won the presidency while losing the national popular vote, after which the compact idea gained traction among legal scholars and supporters.
- 2001Yale law professor Akhil Amar co-wrote an article advancing something close to what became the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
- 2009Wisconsin's Kelda Roys made her first attempt to get her state to join the compact, meeting hesitancy from people unsure what it was.
- 2016Momentum grew after Donald Trump won despite losing the popular vote.
- 2019Nevada's Democratic governor vetoed a bill to join the agreement, saying it could diminish smaller states' influence in presidential elections.
- 2024Maine joined the compact.
- Nov 3, 2026In the midterm elections Democrats won full control in six states representing 71 electoral votes: Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin; other sources count five states.
- Nov 6, 2026Lawmakers in key states said they had begun conversations that week about introducing legislation to join the agreement next session; 18 states and DC had adopted it, representing 222 electoral votes.
- Nov 10, 2026Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro said he would like his newly Democratic legislature to take steps toward making the Electoral College obsolete.
- Nov 12, 2026Vox reported that Yale law professor Akhil Reed Amar now believes the compact has serious flaws.
Key terms
- National Popular Vote compact
- An agreement among U.S. states and D.C. to award all their electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote.
- electoral votes
- A group of presidential electors formed every four years to vote for the president and vice president of the United States.
- midterms
- US general elections held near the midpoint of a president's four-year term, when all House seats and about a third of Senate seats are contested.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Support
- Michigan state Rep. Carrie Rheingans said "the time is right" and that the Democratic wave will help push the compact forward nationwide.
- Support
- Wisconsin Gov. David Crowley said "we can do away with it" and that he is interested in talks with the legislature, now controlled by his party for the first time in 16 years.
- Caution
- Wisconsin Assembly member Clinton Anderson said "time will tell" and that the issue was not what he heard about while knocking on doors.
- Caution
- Maine state Senate president Mattie Daughtry said the biggest roadblock is convincing fellow Democrats to use their new majorities to do big things.
- Expert
- Yale law professor Akhil Reed Amar, an early architect of the idea, now warns it could go badly wrong, comparing it to a doomsday machine.
- Caution
- Former Federal Election Commission member Hans von Spakovsky called the effort "unprecedented" and said he thinks the Supreme Court would rule it cannot be done.
Still unverified
A rumor spread on Instagram and X that Democrats were now in a position to abolish the Electoral College; Snopes says the compact would bypass, not abolish, it, and some experts say congressional approval would be required. It is not certain the strategy has support from all newly elected lawmakers and governors in the key states, and it is almost certain to draw legal challenges from conservative groups.