Analysis examines current state of LLM doomerism
goodmenproject.com

Analysis examines current state of LLM doomerism

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

A blogger argued leading AI companies sell fear as their growth strategy, while author George Kao said evidence for AI-caused human extinction is not likely.
The dispute turns on whether doom talk is a real risk warning or a marketing tool for the labs.

Background

The debate centers on how seriously to treat warnings that advanced AI could end humanity. George Kao, author of a Good Men Project post titled "Beware Of… AI Doomerism. Soulpreneurs, Let's Be Optimists Instead," wrote that the idea of AI-driven extinction is all over the news lately but that the evidence doesn't establish it as likely. A separate blog post, "Doom and Growth," argued the opposite direction: that the leading AI companies' most valuable product is fear itself. The discussion comes after the July 2026 OpenAI-HuggingFace incident, which both sides cite.

How it unfolded

  1. Nov 9, 2026A new supportive subreddit for programmers who don't use LLMs added rules to encourage that choice rather than endless anti-AI doomerism.
  2. Nov 11, 2026George Kao published a post questioning AI doomerism, saying that after research he doesn't think the evidence establishes human extinction via AI as likely.
  3. Nov 11, 2026A podcast panel hosted by Jason Calacanis discussed AI limits; investor Jenny Fielding argued for countering doomerism with concrete hope in health, and Calacanis called the belief that next-token predictors will recursively solve everything a delusion of grandeur.
  4. Nov 13, 2026A blog post titled "Doom and Growth" argued that the most valuable product leading AI companies sell is fear and that doom is their growth strategy.

Key terms

doomerism
A series of large language models developed by Anthropic, released as an AI chatbot and used in software development.
LLMs
A machine learning model trained on huge amounts of text to generate, summarize, translate, and analyze language.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Caution
The "Doom and Growth" blogger argues the leading AI companies sell fear above any model or subscription, that doom is their growth strategy, and that extinction claims are a marketing document in disguise.
Support
George Kao argues the evidence doesn't establish AI-caused human extinction as likely, and that frontier companies like OpenAI and Anthropic will probably have the most advanced AI first and build defender AIs against bad actors.
Analysts
Investor D.A. Wallach said the industry's promise to cure all disease within a decade is a claim he can only price at a 1–5% probability, while Jenny Fielding argued doomerism should be countered with concrete hope in health.
Expert
Host Jason Calacanis called the San Francisco belief that the next-token predictor will recursively solve everything a delusion of grandeur, and investor Ben Lerer described the debate as a binary with no room in between.

Still unverified

The "Doom and Growth" author acknowledged his argument "feels like conspiracy theory territory" before asserting it is the obvious reading of the room, and stated there are very few ways to validate the amount of compute used by labs.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store