Op-ed contrasts democracy's self-correction with Xi's China
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
ASPI's The Strategist published an op-ed by Mike Hughes arguing last week's US midterm election showed democracy can change course, unlike Xi Jinping's China.
The piece feeds a wider debate over whether one-party systems can ever correct themselves.
Background
Xi Jinping has been president of China and Communist Party general secretary since November 2012; the op-ed describes his expansion of party control and suppression of dissent as making him China's most authoritarian leader since Mao. Mike Hughes, an author at ASPI's The Strategist (the Australian Strategic Policy Institute's commentary outlet), wrote the piece after last week's US midterm election, which he presents as an example of democracy's capacity to challenge mistakes and change course. The op-ed also argues the CCP has worked since January 2025 to present China's authoritarian model as more responsible than Donald Trump's America.
How it unfolded
- Nov 2012Xi Jinping becomes Communist Party general secretary; sources date his expansion of party control and suppression of dissent from then.
- 2018Xi removes the two-term limit for the state president and adds Xi Jinping Thought as guiding ideology in the constitution.
- 2022Xi secures a third term as party leader, breaking the post-Mao practice of orderly leadership succession.
- 2022At the 20th National Congress of the CCP, Xi argues China's experience shows the success of a distinct path to modernization rather than emulating other countries' models.
- Jan 2025The CCP works to present China's authoritarian model as a more responsible international stakeholder than President Donald Trump's America.
- Nov 9, 2026An International Affairs article by Julia Bader and Christine Hackenesch is published on CCP diffusion of alternative democracy narratives.
- Nov 12, 2026Pearls and Irritations' Asian Media Report carries Chinese dissident Yang saying the Democratic takeover of Congress shows US democracy retains the capacity to correct itself.
- Nov 13, 2026ASPI's The Strategist publishes Mike Hughes's op-ed "Democracy corrects itself; Xi's China can't."
Key terms
- ASPI
- An Australian defence and strategic policy think tank based in Canberra, founded by the Australian government.
- CCP
- The founding and sole ruling party of the People's Republic of China, founded in 1921.
- whole-process people's democracy
- A Chinese Communist Party political concept describing people's participation in and relationship to governance under socialism with Chinese characteristics.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Analysts
- Mike Hughes argues democracy's greatest strength is not preventing political mistakes but giving citizens a way to challenge them and sometimes change course, and that nothing like that is possible under Xi Jinping's regime.
- Dissident
- Chinese dissident Yang says the Democratic takeover of Congress demonstrates something the CCP would rather the world forget: US democracy retains the capacity to correct itself.
- Official
- Xi Jinping argues China's experience demonstrates the success of a distinct path to modernization, with development achieved through 'whole-process people's democracy' rather than emulating other countries' models.
Still unverified
The op-ed cites a UN human-rights office finding of large-scale arbitrary detention of Uyghurs in Xinjiang, restrictions on religious and other rights, credible allegations of torture or ill-treatment and indications of coercive birth-control and labour practices.