CBC tests six apps' data collection
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
CBC Marketplace tested six popular apps in Canada, including Tim Hortons and PC Optimum, to see what data they collect and where it goes.
The findings center on how much app data flows to outside companies, and what users accept in the terms.
Background
CBC Marketplace is the public broadcaster's consumer-investigation program. It tested six of the most popular Android and iOS apps in Canada — Tim Hortons, PC Optimum, the Weather Network, Facebook, Amazon and YouTube — to find out what data they collect and where it goes, ranging from name and email address to exact whereabouts. The work relied on network traffic analysis by a University of Calgary team led by associate professor Joel Reardon, plus scans by Privo, an organization that evaluates apps for compliance with U.S. child privacy laws. Marketplace says it isn't identifying any of the third-party companies or their locations because accountability rests with the app developer.
How it unfolded
- Nov 13, 2026CBC Marketplace publishes an investigation testing six of the most popular Android and iOS apps in Canada to find out what data they collect and where it goes.
- Nov 13, 2026The Marketplace episode "The App Trap" airs on CBC-TV and CBC Gem, Fridays at 8 p.m. (8:30 p.m. in N.L.).
- Nov 13, 2026Arab Canada News reports on the Marketplace findings.
Key terms
- CBC Marketplace
- A Canadian investigative consumer television program on CBC that tests products and exposes fraudulent business practices.
- Android
- A mobile operating system developed by Google, based on the Linux kernel and open-source software.
- iOS
- Apple's mobile operating system for iPhone, with major versions released annually.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Expert
- University of Calgary associate professor Joel Reardon said the internet has turned into "a monstrous data collection surveillance system," and called the Tim Hortons app's overseas data flow "beyond the pale."
- Analysts
- Reardon and independent analyst Celeste Rollason said the collection seemed more than necessary for the apps to work, questioning why PC Optimum needed 10 outside companies to know what users search for.
- Party
- Tim Hortons communications director Michael Oliveira said the third party collects the information only for fraud prevention, account protection and payment abuse prevention, not for marketing or advertising.
Still unverified
The scan showed the PC Optimum app "appeared to be sending" 10 outside companies information about which products users search for, including sensitive products like prenatal vitamins, and one third party "appeared to be receiving" a user's latitude, longitude and a device-unique identifier; the Tim Hortons app "appeared to be sending" data to third parties as soon as it launches, with one overseas third party "appeared to be receiving" enough to create a digital fingerprint per device. The network scan map shows activity from all apps on someone's phone, not necessarily the apps Marketplace tested.