C++ standard fails national bodies vote
theregister.com

C++ standard fails national bodies vote

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

The C++26 draft failed its ISO national-body ballot with 9 negative votes out of 22.
The rejection delays the standard and exposes a rift over the Contracts feature.

Background

C++ is one of the world's most widely used programming languages, and Bjarne Stroustrup is its creator. The draft standard for its next version, C++26, must pass a series of ISO (International Organization for Standardization) votes, and the national-body ballot is normally a formality because disagreements are expected to be settled earlier by WG21 (Working Group 21, the C++ Standards Committee). This time the draft was voted down, with the disputed Contracts feature — standardized runtime checks including pre- and post-conditions — as the sticking point, and Stroustrup among those opposing it in its current form.

How it unfolded

  1. date unknownContracts were abruptly removed from C++20 over concerns about dangerous defaults, after developers had proposed adding them for at least a decade.
  2. Aug 2026Bjarne Stroustrup and colleagues published a paper calling the P2900 Contracts design fundamentally flawed and an existential threat to C++.
  3. Oct 2026The C++26 Draft International Standard failed its ISO ballot, the next-to-last approval stage. Robert Seacord reported 12 of 20 P-Members in favor (60%, requirement at least 66.66%) and 9 negative votes out of 22 member bodies (41%, requirement at most 25%).
  4. Nov 11, 2026An article reported the rejection as unprecedented for a C++ ISO draft, with Contracts the divisive issue.
  5. Nov 13, 2026Reports said the failure puts the expected release this year at risk; if released next year the official name would be ISO/IEC 14882:2027, with C++27 only an informal name.
  6. Nov 2026ISO C++ working group WG21 was due to meet the following week in Búzios, Brazil.

Key terms

ISO national-body ballot
A vote by the member national standards bodies of the International Organization for Standardization on whether to approve a draft standard.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Caution
Bjarne Stroustrup and colleagues argued the P2900 Contracts design is fundamentally flawed, adding insecurities and complexity and posing an existential threat to C++.
Support
Committee member Andreas Fertig said the topic had been worked on for years and passed a majority vote multiple times, and that the no vote shook an established system based on trust and respectful collaboration.
Analysts
Herb Sutter noted that for the first time in 36 years Stroustrup considers a feature decision so wrong that the draft should not be approved.
Official
C++ Alliance CEO Harry Bott said the draft being sent back is the process working as intended, and the goal should be to learn from it and strengthen the process.
Public
J. Daniel García said the 12 abstentions, in several cases because countries could not reach a common position, are another signal of a contested draft.

Still unverified

The blog post reporting the ballot result said 'if the above posts are correct' the draft failed both bars, and that it heard the US abstained 'but take that with a grain of salt.'

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store