AI erodes trust between writers and readers
theatlantic.com

AI erodes trust between writers and readers

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

A reader told novelist Rachel Kadish her novel's Parkinson's character chose assisted suicide, a plot she never wrote.
Readers and writers now question who, or what, actually wrote what they read.

Background

Rachel Kadish is a novelist and essayist, author of The Weight of Ink. At a book signing in late 2025, a man with Parkinson's told her he understood her novel featured a character with Parkinson's who chose assisted suicide; Kadish says the character does not end her own life. She had earlier asked ChatGPT about the novel, which gave this false rendition of the plotline, and she wondered how many other readers had been similarly misled. The episode is one of several cited as evidence that AI is straining trust between writers and readers.

How it unfolded

  1. 2024Anil Doshi and Oliver Hauser found in Science Advances that writers given ideas by an AI wrote stories readers rated more novel and more useful, but the stories grew more alike.
  2. Jun 2025A small MIT study released as a preprint found people who wrote essays with ChatGPT showed the weakest brain connectivity of three groups, felt the least ownership of their essays and struggled to quote what they had just written.
  3. late 2025At a book signing, a man with Parkinson's told novelist Rachel Kadish he understood her novel The Weight of Ink featured a character with Parkinson's who chose assisted suicide; Kadish says the character does not end her own life.
  4. Jan 2026Anthropic published a randomized experiment with programmers learning a new software library; those who let the assistant write the code scored 17 percent lower on a test of understanding and saved almost no time.
  5. Nov 2026After a new reader-facing chatbot rolled out across USA Today websites, guild journalists at two Ohio papers pulled their bylines, saying the bot misidentified the reporter covering a murder case as the suspect.

Key terms

preprint
A version of a scholarly paper that is shared before formal peer review and journal publication.
guild journalists
Journalists who are members of the NewsGuild-CWA, a labor union founded by newspaper journalists in 1933.
Palantir
An American publicly traded company that develops data integration and analytics software, founded in 2003.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Expert
Novelist Rachel Kadish says she was horrified that a reader objected to a plot point she had not written, and wondered how many others had been similarly misled.
Party
Writer Pedro Santa Clara, who uses Claude in his process, says some people stop reading his work once they learn this, and argues we should judge the work more than how it was made.
Caution
The McGill Daily editorial board says there is no room for AI at any stage of writing or editing, calling journalism a public service built on trust between reader and reporter.
Party
NewsGuild president Jon Schleuss criticized executives who 'speak in this weird, AI-written code-speak' while not raising pay, and guild members at USA Today papers demanded an end to the Palantir deal.

Still unverified

Kadish did not know for certain where the reader's misunderstanding had originated, but guessed it came from her earlier ChatGPT queries about the novel.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store