Security blogger Soatok rebuts cryptography conspiracy theories, tracing DES distrust to 1975
penguinrandomhouse.com

Security blogger Soatok rebuts cryptography conspiracy theories, tracing DES distrust to 1975

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

Security blogger Soatok published a post arguing most cryptography conspiracy theories make no technical sense.
The piece traces decades of government-distrust claims and a November internet-blackout rumor.

Background

Soatok is the author of the "Dhole Moments" blog, writing about software, security, cryptography and furries; he says he has never held a security clearance and has access to the same facts as anyone else. His post argues that distrust of the US government and the NSA (National Security Agency) has been politically primed since the 2013 Snowden disclosures, and that many cryptography conspiracy theories rest on technical arguments that don't hold up. He says his goal is not to make readers trust any government, but to show governments are not magical or omniscient.

How it unfolded

  1. 1975The Data Encryption Standard (DES) was published in the Federal Register, and Martin Hellman wrote to the National Bureau of Standards warning it might be vulnerable to attack by an intelligence organization.
  2. 1977DES was standardized.
  3. 1998The EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) cracked DES with hardware costing about $250,000.
  4. 2013The Snowden disclosures occurred, which the author says politically primed him to directionally agree with distrusting the US government wholesale.
  5. Jul 13, 2017WikiLeaks published part 17 of its Vault 7 releases, the manual for project "Highrise" (Tidecheck), used to intercept and redirect SMS messages on Android 4.0-4.3.
  6. Jul 19, 2017WikiLeaks published part 18, Raytheon Blackbird Technologies documents for the "UMBRAGE Component Library" project.
  7. Jul 27, 2017WikiLeaks published part 19, manuals for project "Imperial", including tools Achilles, Aeris and SeaPea.
  8. Nov 1, 2026A Brazilian X user going by the handle Wesley posted, citing an anonymous "source on the dark web", a scenario of impending collapse advising people to stockpile food, water, cash, precious metals and firearms.
  9. Nov 17, 2026A nationwide one-minute test of the Emergency Alert System by FEMA and the FCC was scheduled in the US, announced back in September.
  10. Nov 2026Social media and messaging apps worldwide were swept by rumors of a global catastrophe on November 17, in which hackers would breach major banks, wipe out accounts and shut down the internet for three months.

Key terms

DES
A symmetric-key block cipher for encrypting digital data, standardized in the 1970s with a 56-bit key.
NSA
A U.S. Department of Defense intelligence agency responsible for signals intelligence and protecting government communications.
Vault 7
A series of documents WikiLeaks published in 2017 detailing CIA electronic surveillance and cyber warfare capabilities.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Expert
Blog author Soatok argues most technical arguments in cryptography conspiracy theories make no sense, and that the aim is not to make readers trust governments but to show they are not magical or omniscient.
Official
Relevant agencies said the FEMA/FCC emergency alert signal would not even be sent to smartphones and would not affect the internet in any way.
Caution
The author of the November 1 X post said the information was unverified and should not be taken literally.

Still unverified

The November 1 X post cited an anonymous "source on the dark web"; its author said the information was unverified and should not be taken literally, and the disclaimer was often dropped as the message spread. The original source of the November 17 panic is only "believed to be" Wesley's post. In the crypto community, two mutually exclusive theories emerged: one predicting Bitcoin would crash alongside fiat currencies, and another claiming it would become the sole surviving asset.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store