New York teen Robin Murphy vanished in 1995; ABC's 20/20 revisits the case
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
17-year-old Robin Murphy disappeared in Carmel, New York, in April 1995 and has never been found.
A new two-hour 20/20 special links her case to another local girl's murder.
Background
Robin Murphy was a 17-year-old who worked at a ShopRite in Carmel, New York, a town in Putnam County. She disappeared on April 9, 1995, after going to meet her boyfriend at the Burger King in the same shopping plaza, and her case has remained unsolved. Months earlier, 12-year-old Josette Wright had vanished from the same town; her remains were found in 1995. ABC's "20/20" revisited both cases in a two-hour episode, "Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County School Girls," which aired Nov. 13, 2026.
How it unfolded
- Oct 3, 199412-year-old Josette Wright is last seen coming off a school bus near her Carmel, New York home.
- Apr 9, 199517-year-old Robin Murphy disappears after going to meet her boyfriend Matt Esposito for dinner at the Burger King in the ShopRite Plaza on Route 52 in Carmel. Her mother's red Oldsmobile is later found abandoned in the parking lot.
- Apr 13, 1995Coworkers and friends organize a civilian search of the woods behind the ShopRite and find Murphy's work schedule and paystub.
- 1995Murphy's keys, checkbook, wallet and ID are found in a grassy area behind the shopping center. Police interview Howard Gombert, a laundromat worker at the plaza, who says he met Murphy for about 10 minutes that night and denied knowing what happened to her.
- Thanksgiving weekend 1995Josette Wright's skeletal remains are found in a wooded area near Fields Lane in Putnam County.
- 1997Anthony DiPippo and Andrew Krivak are convicted in separate trials of the murder and rape of Josette Wright and sentenced to 25 years to life.
- 2000Gombert is arrested and convicted of sexually assaulting his former girlfriend; he is later also convicted of sexually assaulting a 7-year-old girl in Connecticut, for 30 years total.
- 2016DiPippo is acquitted of all charges and released after serving almost 20 years.
- 2020Krivak is released from prison.
- 2024Remains found in the area are tested against Robin Murphy's DNA; it does not come back a match.
- Apr 2025Carmel Police Chief Anthony Hoffmann says authorities are still investigating the cold case, following new leads and asking the public for help.
- Nov 13, 2026ABC's "20/20" airs the two-hour episode "Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County School Girls," examining the Wright and Murphy cases.
Key terms
- 25 years to life
- A prison sentence that keeps a convicted person locked up for the rest of their life with no chance of release.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Family
- Robin's brother Jamie Murphy said finding her belongings was "like a stab in the chest because now it's getting real," recalling a gut feeling something was wrong when he got the call.
- Official
- Carmel Police Chief Anthony Hoffmann said authorities were still investigating the cold case and following new leads, and asked the public for help.
- Expert
- Investigative journalist Paul Solotaroff, host of the podcast "Bone Valley Season 6: Devil's Quarry II," described how coworkers and friends organized a civilian search of the woods behind the ShopRite four days after Murphy went missing.
Still unverified
Howard Gombert emerged as an alternate suspect in the Wright case and a suspect in Murphy's disappearance but has not been convicted in connection with either girl; rumors and speculation have surrounded both cases for three decades. The Exoneration Project, per an ABC report, says evidence shows Krivak was coerced by police into signing a false statement confessing to raping and murdering Wright.