Jonathan Blow questions AI coding claims
redd.it

Jonathan Blow questions AI coding claims

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

Game developer Jonathan Blow said if AI could code as claimed, it would be the most valuable company.
Developers pushed back, saying small AI-assisted teams now ship better games.

Background

Jonathan Blow is a veteran programmer and video game developer known for Braid, The Witness and The Order of the Sinking Star. In a video on The Students, a YouTube channel with 44.2K subscribers, he and discussion partner Wolf Tivy argued that software has grown more complex and unreliable and that today's AI can't produce better code than people. The discussion is framed against the AI boom since Blow's 2019 speech on the collapse of civilization, which focused on software and drew both responses and disagreement.

How it unfolded

  1. Feb 25, 2025Blow responds on X to vibe coder Levelsio, who had shared a flight simulator built entirely with AI, saying getting something on the screen is easy but making the game good is hard.
  2. Nov 13, 2026The Students posts a video of Blow and Wolf Tivy discussing the explosion of software complexity and why today's AI can't produce better code than people.
  3. Nov 13, 2026The video is submitted to Hacker News, reaching 144 points and 130 comments.

Key terms

Hacker News
A social news website focused on computer science and entrepreneurship, run by Y Combinator.
vibe coder
A software development practice where a person describes a task in natural language to an AI model that generates the code.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Expert
Blow argues that if AI could really do what people claim with code, that would probably be the most valuable company in the world.
Caution
Blow says commercial software has been a 'wild west' where failures are so common and mundane that everybody accepts them.

Still unverified

Hacker News commenters dispute Blow's position, arguing indie games have improved in quality and complexity and that AI agents are a significant improvement in coding experience; some also claim his stance stems from ego and hostility to making code more accessible to non-programmers.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store