DOS space sim reviewed but never released
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
PC Gamer reviewed Renegade II: Return to Jacob's Star at 71% even though the DOS space sim never reached shops.
Preservationists now want former staff and press who may hold a copy to come forward.
Background
Renegade II: Return to Jacob's Star was the sequel to Renegade: Battle for Jacob's Star, a fighter-combat space sim set in the Renegade Legion universe that Strategic Simulations, Inc. (SSI) published in 1995, developed by Midnight Software. SSI's catalogue advertised the sequel with 50 missions, two new flyable ships and modem head-to-head dogfights, and PC Gamer reviewed it, but the game was cancelled and never sold. The trail for a complete copy now runs through old magazines, a publisher catalogue and a small demo download.
How it unfolded
- 1995SSI published Midnight Software's original Renegade: Battle for Jacob's Star, a fighter-cockpit space sim with Super VGA graphics, cinematic sequences and digitised speech.
- Sep 1996Computer Gaming World reported the cancellation of Renegade II: Return to Jacob's Star and grouped it with projects it described as nearly complete.
- 2023SNEG brought the first game back to Steam and GOG.
- this weekGames That Weren't published a preservation appeal after hearing from researcher Mikael Magnano, asking former Midnight Software and SSI staff and journalists who might have received a copy to get in touch.
- Nov 14, 2026A Reddit r/retrogaming post described an article about the cancelled sim, the one mission playable in a browser, and the search for a more complete copy.
Key terms
- space sim
- A genre of flight simulator video games that lets players experience space flight, exploration, trade and combat.
- Renegade Legion universe
- A science fiction game setting created by Sam Lewis and produced by FASA in the late 1980s and early 1990s.
- Super VGA
- A broad term for computer display standards that extended IBM's original VGA specification.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Expert
- PC Gamer's Todd Vaughn, reviewing the game at 71%, liked the sharp graphics and multiplayer but had less time for the controls and wanted more variety from the missions.
- Official
- SSI's catalogue advertised 50 missions, the Peacekeeper and Defiant ships, and modem head-to-head dogfights.
- Support
- Games That Weren't is asking former staff at Midnight Software and SSI, and journalists who might have received a copy, to get in touch.
Still unverified
Researcher Mikael Magnano's research points to possible advance copies sent to members of the European games press. It is also unknown whether the PC Gamer reviewer was playing a build still in development, how many missions they could reach, whether they played against someone else in the office, and any date or version number on the disc.