Datacenter industry accused of propaganda tactics
bizpacreview.com

Datacenter industry accused of propaganda tactics

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

Three University of Pittsburgh researchers published a Guardian opinion article accusing data-center companies of using propaganda to weaken local opposition.
The piece cites Google paying The Dalles, Oregon's legal fees after records on a data center's water use were withheld.

Background

Samuel Woolley, Dean Jackson and Maia Woluchem are researchers affiliated with the University of Pittsburgh's Communication Technology Research Lab; Woluchem also directs Data & Society's Trustworthy Infrastructures Program. In a Guardian opinion article, they argue that data-center companies and their allies use propaganda, disinformation and information control to mold public opinion and undercut community opposition. They point to campaign spending routed through opaque nonprofits that conceal donors, advertised tax revenue that can omit tax breaks, and closed-loop cooling that can cut a facility's direct water use while some demand shifts to the power plants generating its electricity. The authors call for enforceable transparency rules.

How it unfolded

  1. Nov 13, 2026The three researchers publish a Guardian opinion article arguing the data-center industry uses propaganda, disinformation and information control to weaken local opposition.
  2. Nov 13, 2026The article cites Google paying the city of The Dalles, Oregon, its legal fees after officials withheld records on a data center's water use, with a later settlement providing for the records' release.
  3. Nov 13, 2026It cites Build American AI advertising 57,785 Texas jobs, which the researchers say does not show how many are permanent, how many go to subcontractors, or whether workers get benefits.
  4. Nov 13, 2026The article names Elevate New Mexico as a group presenting itself as a local initiative while obscuring corporate connections in the data-center business, and cites Kevin O'Leary calling two critics.

Key terms

closed-loop cooling
Cooling equipment that removes waste heat from computer hardware to keep components within safe temperature limits.
nonprofits
An organization that operates for public or social benefit rather than to generate profit for private owners.
tax breaks
A government tax policy measure that encourages a particular economic activity by reducing tax payments.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Researchers
Woolley, Jackson and Woluchem argue the industry uses propaganda, disinformation and information control, including opaque nonprofit spending and incomplete tax and water figures, to undermine community opposition, and call for enforceable transparency rules.
Industry critics
Data-center critics have described claims that China-linked actors drive opposition as using China as a bogeyman.

Still unverified

The article's characterization of the industry's conduct is presented as the authors' critical interpretation, alongside examples and accounts from local organizers.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store