Op-ed: Democrats use identity politics against progressives
unherd.com

Op-ed: Democrats use identity politics against progressives

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

Guardian columnist Arwa Mahdawi wrote that corporate Democrats weaponize identity politics to smear progressives.
The post-midterm argument is over what the left's message should be now.

Background

The pieces follow the 2026 midterm elections, which sources describe as a historic transfer of power to the Democratic Party and a repudiation of the Republican Party. Arwa Mahdawi is a Guardian opinion columnist; Shadi Hamid writes for UnHerd as a progressive; Catherine Liu is a left-wing cultural critic and author of "Traumatized: The New Politics of Public Suffering"; Christine Rosen guest-hosted a New York Times "Interesting Times" episode. UnHerd argues that "wokeness" receded in many progressive institutions after Trump's 2024 victory and was no longer the animating issue in 2026, while a West Hollywood op-ed questions what "progressive" now means in local politics.

How it unfolded

  1. Nov 8, 2026A West Hollywood op-ed on the City Council election says emerging results suggest "the most progressive government money can buy," with at least two candidates benefiting from substantial independent spending backed by commercial interests including billboard companies.
  2. Nov 10, 2026An UnHerd column by Shadi Hamid says the Left has hope after a "stunning repudiation of the Republican Party in the midterms" and argues it must resist re-entertaining racial and gender-based identity politics.
  3. Nov 12, 2026A New York Times "Interesting Times" episode with Catherine Liu asks whether America is over identity politics, after guest host Christine Rosen calls the midterms a "historic transfer of power to the Democratic Party."
  4. Nov 14, 2026Arwa Mahdawi's Guardian column says House members responded to legitimate criticism with cynicism and warns against another "Bernie bros" moment.

Key terms

identity politics
Politics organized around a shared group identity such as race, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.
midterm elections
US general elections held near the midpoint of a president's four-year term, when all House seats and about a third of Senate seats are contested.
NGO industrial complex
An organization independent of government, typically nonprofit, often focused on humanitarian or social issues.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Party
Arwa Mahdawi argues corporate Democrats are weaponizing identity politics to smear progressives, and that House members met legitimate criticism with cynicism.
Analysts
Shadi Hamid, writing as a progressive, argues the Left must resist re-entertaining racial and gender-based identity politics, saying the midterms were not a mandate for divisive cultural politics.
Expert
Catherine Liu argues America is not over identity politics, that there will be a lot of resistance to its demise, and that too much is at stake within the NGO industrial complex to abandon wielding trauma as a blunt instrument.
Public
A WEHOville op-ed writer argues "progressive" has evolved from a political philosophy into something resembling a commercial trademark, and that West Hollywood politics has become an expression of identity rather than deliberation.

Still unverified

The West Hollywood op-ed says votes were still being counted and results were emerging, and states it is not suggesting every campaign contribution purchases a vote or that independent political spending establishes wrongdoing.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store