Amazon discounts found illusory in pricing study
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
Groundwork Collaborative found 29.1% of 351 Amazon holiday deal products sold at or above their prior 30-day low.
Amazon calls the findings flawed, so the dispute is over how deals are measured.
Background
Groundwork Collaborative is a progressive economic policy think tank; its report, "Deal or Decoy? Amazon's Deceptive Discounts," was co-authored by president and CEO Lindsay Owens. It examined products on Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025 — pages Amazon itself promoted as handpicked best discounts — and compared sale prices with each item's recent lows. The report lands days before Amazon's Black Friday Week sale was scheduled to start, and Amazon rejects its methodology.
How it unfolded
- Nov 16, 2026Groundwork releases its report, finding 29.1% of 351 products on Amazon's 2024 and 2025 Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages sold at the same price or higher than their lowest price in the prior 30 days, and 9.4% cost more during the sale.
- Nov 16, 2026Groundwork says that among products priced higher during the sale, the median increase over the earlier low was 19%; stretching the look-back to 90 days, 57.3% offered no savings over their recent low.
- Nov 16, 2026The report cites examples including Hunter rain boots at $126.99 on Black Friday 2025 that had been $79.97 nine days earlier, and UGG Butte boots at $179.98 on Cyber Monday 2025 that had been $98.40 about four weeks earlier.
- Nov 16, 2026Amazon removes the deal pages after learning of the study, according to the report.
- Nov 17, 2026Amazon disputes the findings, saying Groundwork included products that never carried deal badges and used inaccurate prices in some comparisons.
- Nov 19, 2026Amazon's Black Friday Week sale is scheduled to start, three days after the report.
Key terms
- think tank
- An organization that researches and advocates on policy topics such as economics, politics, and technology.
- Black Friday
- The Friday after Thanksgiving in the US, marking the start of the Christmas shopping season with heavily discounted sales.
- Cyber Monday
- The Monday after Thanksgiving in the US, promoted to encourage online shopping with sales.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Analysts
- Groundwork says nearly 1 in 3 deals offered no real savings and nearly 1 in 10 were more expensive, warning shoppers who wait for major sale events "may be playing rip-off roulette."
- Official
- Groundwork president Lindsay Owens says shoppers trust advertised deals to deliver real savings and that lawmakers should hold Amazon accountable if it can't.
- Party
- Amazon calls the findings "deeply flawed and false claims," says the sample was cherry-picked and misread its list prices, and counts 98% of sampled products in 2024 and 99% in 2025 as meeting its 30-day low-price test.
Still unverified
Amazon claims Groundwork's sample was "cherry-picked" and that some products never carried deal badges and some prices were inaccurate; Groundwork stands by its findings.