State Farm to pay $45M after Oklahoma insurance probe
oklahomavoice.com

State Farm to pay $45M after Oklahoma insurance probe

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

Oklahoma's insurance department reached a $45 million settlement with State Farm over denied wind and hail roof claims.
State Farm admits no wrongdoing; the attorney general calls the deal a shield.

Background

State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. is an Illinois-based insurer and Oklahoma's largest homeowners insurer, with more than 258,000 customers and $785.9 million in homeowners premiums in 2025 — over 30% of the market. Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready, a Republican leaving office in January after two terms, opened a market conduct examination in May 2022 after policyholders complained to FOX23 about claim problems, and the review followed Oklahoma Watch reporting that Oklahoma stood out among neighboring states for high homeowner premiums. The settlement covers wind and hail roof damage claims closed without payment between 2021 and 2025.

How it unfolded

  1. May 2022Oklahoma's insurance department began its market conduct examination of State Farm, according to Commissioner Glen Mulready.
  2. 2021 –2025The settlement covers wind and hail roof damage claims closed without payment during this period.
  3. Jun 2026Attorney General Gentner Drummond sued State Farm in Cleveland County District Court, one day after the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled he couldn't intervene in a private case filed two months earlier, Hursh v. State Farm.
  4. Nov 3, 2026Republican Bob Sullivan won the general election for insurance commissioner with 59% of the vote.
  5. Nov 13, 2026Mulready announced the completed examination and a $45 million settlement: at least $35 million for customer claims, $10 million for the Strengthen Oklahoma Homes grant program, and $2.86 million in fines and examination expenses.
  6. Nov 16, 2026Mulready publicly touted the settlement; incoming commissioner Bob Sullivan said he was still learning the details.
  7. Dec 31, 2026Deadline for State Farm to notify affected consumers with instructions on having denied claims reviewed.

Key terms

Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act
A strike protesting actions by an employer or union that violate labor law, such as the National Labor Relations Act.
bad-faith claims
A tort claim that an insurer violated the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in an insurance contract.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Official
Mulready said the department put independent engineers in the field rather than taking State Farm's word, found nearly two dozen violations of the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act, and set aside at least $35 million for consumers who may have been wrongfully denied.
Company
State Farm said it disagrees with the findings and characterizations, that it evaluates each claim on the loss facts and the customer's policy, that it handled more than 100,000 Oklahoma claims over five years, and that the financial commitments were a negotiated resolution, not a punitive fine.
Caution
Attorney General Gentner Drummond called the settlement a last-ditch effort to protect State Farm, saying homeowners must sign away bad-faith claims and drop lawsuits to get paid, leftover money returns to the company, and the deal bars further penalties and a new examination for 12 months.
Analysts
Incoming commissioner Bob Sullivan said the deal looked like good news for policyholders whose roof claims were denied and who haven't sued, but that it takes some regulatory flexibility off the table.

Still unverified

State Farm denies wrongdoing and disputes the examination's findings and characterizations; Drummond disputes the settlement's consumer-protection value, describing its terms as giving State Farm a way out.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store