UK forced to disclose Apple secret encryption order
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
A UK tribunal ordered the government to confirm whether it issued a secret technical notice to Apple.
The ruling lifts secrecy on orders that can weaken UK users' encrypted iCloud data.
Background
Apple, the California-based iPhone maker, received a Technical Capability Notice (a secret government order compelling a company to help security services and law enforcement) demanding a backdoor into encrypted cloud data. Britain issued the order under rules barring companies from revealing it, and Apple challenged it at the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, a specialist British court that hears challenges against investigatory powers and the intelligence agencies. The case drew wider attention after details leaked and US officials criticized the order as putting Americans' privacy at risk.
How it unfolded
- 2022Apple introduced Advanced Data Protection (ADP), extending end-to-end encryption to almost all iCloud data so Apple has no access; the feature is off by default.
- Jan 2025Britain issued an initial technical capability notice seeking a backdoor to encrypted cloud backups of US and British citizens' data.
- Feb 2025Rather than comply, Apple stopped allowing new UK users to enable iCloud Advanced Data Protection.
- Jul 2025After the first demand was dropped following negotiations with US President Donald Trump's administration, Britain issued a second notice applying just to Apple's UK customers, and Apple launched a renewed challenge.
- Sep 2026Civil rights groups and Apple told the tribunal that the government's 'neither confirm nor deny' policy was an affront to open justice and prevented meaningful public discussion.
- Nov 19, 2026The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ordered the government to acknowledge whether it issued any Technical Capability Notices to Apple, rejecting the Home Office's claim that disclosure would damage national security.
- Dec 2026A substantive hearing in Privacy International and Liberty's separate challenge is scheduled.
Key terms
- tribunal
- A person or institution with authority to judge or determine claims and disputes, not necessarily a court.
- Technical Capability Notice
- A secret UK order compelling a company to help authorities access data under surveillance law.
- Investigatory Powers Tribunal
- A UK tribunal and superior court of record that primarily hears national security and surveillance cases.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Support
- Privacy International legal director Caroline Wilson Palow called the judgment 'a major victory for transparency and effective oversight' and said the government cannot claim secrecy in legal challenges while dropping it when revelations serve political ends.
- Support
- Liberty director Akiko Hart said the public deserve to know when government actions undermine their privacy and safety, welcoming a decision that will 'shine more light on these secretive powers.'
- Caution
- A British government lawyer argued that abandoning the 'neither confirm nor deny' stance posed a national security risk and would 'provide material assistance to hostile actors.'
- Official
- Apple said it has 'never built a backdoor or master key' and 'never will,' and is 'gravely disappointed' that ADP protections will not be available to UK customers.
Still unverified
The narrower replacement notice reportedly focuses on UK users. The ruling does not determine whether the underlying demands are lawful or whether Apple has built a backdoor. The tribunal said it handed down private judgments that could not be disclosed without 'damaging the public interest.'