UK admits secret Apple encryption order
9to5mac.com

UK admits secret Apple encryption order

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

A UK tribunal ruled the government must acknowledge it issued Apple a secret technical capability notice.
The order pushed Apple to pull its end-to-end encrypted iCloud feature for UK users.

Background

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal is the UK court that hears certain national security cases. The dispute centres on Apple's Advanced Data Protection (ADP), a feature introduced in 2022 that extends end-to-end encryption to almost all iCloud data so Apple itself has no access. Technical Capability Notices are secret orders under Section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 that can require tech companies to change their services to aid investigations; recipients are legally barred from discussing them. The government had kept a "neither confirm nor deny" stance on the notice even though its existence was widely reported.

How it unfolded

  1. Jan 2025The order was reportedly issued under the Investigatory Powers Act.
  2. Feb 2025The Washington Post reported the government had ordered Apple to provide 'backdoor' access to encrypted iCloud data worldwide; Apple withdrew ADP for British users.
  3. Apr 2025The Investigatory Powers Tribunal acknowledged it would hear Apple's claim over the notice regime.
  4. Aug 2025After diplomatic wrangling involving the Trump administration, the UK government withdrew the original notice.
  5. Oct 2025The Financial Times reported a second notice understood to be limited to the UK.
  6. Jul 2026A replacement notice reportedly targeting UK users was issued; Apple filed its current challenge.
  7. Sep 17, 2026At a tribunal hearing, Apple's lawyers demanded the Home Office admit to the secret order.
  8. Nov 19, 2026The tribunal ruled the government must acknowledge it issued Apple a technical capability notice, rejecting its 'neither confirm nor deny' policy.
  9. 2027A substantive hearing is scheduled for the first half of 2027; the ruling did not decide whether the notice is lawful.

Key terms

Investigatory Powers Tribunal
A UK tribunal and superior court of record that primarily hears national security and surveillance cases.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Official
Security Minister Dan Jarvis and Westminster officials say they do not comment on operational matters, including confirming or denying such notices, citing national security.
Analysts
Information security lecturer Andrew Dwyer argues a notice capable of removing an encryption service from millions of users is not like a live operation and should not be shielded the same way.
Support
Apple says it has never built a backdoor or master key and never will, and is gravely disappointed UK users lose ADP protections.
Caution
Privacy International and Liberty are challenging the lawfulness and secrecy of the notice regime, arguing weakened encryption threatens personal privacy and security.

Still unverified

The precise technical requirements of the notice remain undisclosed; it appears Apple effectively complied by withdrawing ADP for British users. The second notice is understood to be limited to the UK, though Privacy International maintains its impact is still global.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store