Trump judicial nominee Sullivan falters on 22nd Amendment at Senate hearing
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
Texas Supreme Court Justice James Sullivan struggled to recite the 22nd Amendment at his Senate confirmation hearing.
The exchange puts Trump's repeated third-term talk against the Constitution's two-term limit.
Background
James P. Sullivan is a Texas Supreme Court justice, appointed by Gov. Greg Abbott in early 2025, and a former general counsel to the governor; Trump nominated him to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas. The 22nd Amendment, ratified in 1951 after Franklin D. Roosevelt's four elected terms, states that no person shall be elected to the presidency more than twice. The hearing came as the administration pushed to confirm nominees before a Democratic majority takes over the Senate, and after Trump repeatedly said he was "not joking" about pursuing a third term.
How it unfolded
- Mar 2025Trump first used the phrase he was "not joking" about pursuing a third term, during a phone call with NBC News's Kristin Welker.
- Apr 22, 2025In a Time magazine interview, Trump said "There are some loopholes that have been discussed that are well known" for keeping him in power.
- Nov 2026Texas Supreme Court Justice James P. Sullivan lost his reelection bid as the state saw a "blue wave" in the midterm elections; days later Trump nominated him to become a federal judge in Texas.
- Nov 18, 2026At a Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing, Sen. Chris Coons asked Sullivan what the 22nd Amendment provides; Sullivan whispered "Oh boy, oh boy" before Coons prompted him with "No person shall be elected…"
- Nov 18, 2026Asked whether Trump is eligible to run again in 2028, Sullivan declined to answer, citing Canon 5; nominee William Lambert said the amendment "seems clear that no one may serve a third term" and "would include anyone."
- Nov 18, 2026Later in the hearing, Sen. Richard Blumenthal asked nominees whether they were "willing to say the Capitol was attacked" on January 6, 2021; none responded, and he said, "Nobody? It's a sad day."
Key terms
- 22nd Amendment
- Constitutional amendment limiting a person to being elected President of the United States no more than twice.
- Canon 5
- A section of the US Supreme Court's code of conduct governing when justices should refrain from political or extrajudicial statements.
- blue wave
- An election in which the Democratic Party makes major gains, named after the blue color associated with Democrats.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Support
- Coons said the amendment is "bracingly clear" and that the third-term question "is only unresolved in the mind of President Trump," calling Sullivan's answer "a very disappointing answer."
- Caution
- Sullivan said opining on Trump's 2028 eligibility would violate Canon 5 for a judicial nominee and called it "the sort of thing that is a subject of ongoing political debate."
- Party
- Fellow nominee William Lambert said the 22nd Amendment "seems clear that no one may serve a third term" and "That would include anyone, Senator."
Still unverified
Sullivan described Trump's 2028 eligibility as "the sort of thing that is a subject of ongoing political debate," a characterization Coons disputed.