Carnival Cruises sulphur emissions exceed Europe's cars
euronews.com

Carnival Cruises sulphur emissions exceed Europe's cars

Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.

The gist

Carnival Corporation's 63 ships produced more sulphur oxide than all European cars combined, a 2022 analysis found.
Europe's 214 cruise ships still out-polluted a billion cars, keeping port rules in focus.

Background

Carnival Corporation is the world's largest cruise operator, and Transport & Environment (T&E), a sustainable transport group, has repeatedly analysed the fleet's emissions. Its studies found cruise ships burning heavy fuel oil release sulphur oxide (SOx) and nitrogen oxide (NOx) far out of proportion to their numbers, concentrated around port cities. The issue keeps resurfacing because shipping long went largely unregulated, and emission control areas (ECAs) — zones with stricter fuel limits — cover only the North and Baltic Seas and the English Channel.

How it unfolded

  1. 2017A T&E analysis found Carnival Corporation emitted nearly 10 times more sulphur oxide around European coasts than all 260 million European cars; Royal Caribbean ranked second but was still four times worse than the car fleet.
  2. 2020The International Maritime Organization set a global cap on sulphur in ships' fuel oil, expected to cut overall ship sulphur emissions by 77%.
  3. 2022A T&E study found Europe's 214 cruise ships emitted 509 tonnes of sulphur oxide, 19,125 tonnes of nitrogen oxide and 448 tonnes of PM2.5; Carnival's 63 ships alone produced more sulphur oxide than all European cars combined.
  4. 2023T&E reported the 218 cruise ships in European waters emitted the sulphur oxide equivalent of a billion cars, and that Carnival emitted 2.5 million tonnes of CO2 — more than Glasgow's 2021 level.

Key terms

sulphur oxide
A group of chemical compounds made of sulfur and oxygen, produced by volcanoes and by burning fossil fuels.
heavy fuel oil
A thick, tar-like residual fuel left after refining crude oil, used to power large ships.
emission control areas
Sea zones where stricter limits apply to airborne emissions from ships under MARPOL rules.

Source: Wikipedia

Who’s saying what

Expert
T&E shipping policy manager Faig Abbasov called luxury cruise ships 'floating cities powered by some of the dirtiest fuel possible' and said governments must mandate zero-emission standards.
Caution
The Eco Discussion Facebook page argued that corporate 'zero-emission' cruising promises deserve healthy skepticism and that strict port regulations and accountability are needed.
Party
Campaigners from Ecohustler disrupted Carnival's AGM, calling on shareholders to reduce the company's pollution.

Still unverified

Carnival and Royal Caribbean have announced plans to deploy zero-emission ships by the 2030s, but these remain prototypes and commercial adoption could take decades.

Sources

See today’s stories in the app Gistline — free on the App Store