NYC Mayor Mamdani proposes closing Rikers Island jail by 2032
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani proposed closing Rikers Island by 2032, extending the legal deadline from 2027.
The plan needs City Council approval and a smaller jail population.
Background
Rikers Island has housed New York City jail inmates since the 1930s and has long been a symbol of dysfunction, with the jail network plagued by violence and overcrowding; a federal judge, citing "abnormal and unacceptable" conditions, appointed an outside manager to restore order. In 2019 the City Council voted to close the complex and replace it with four smaller borough jails by 2027, but the city is all but certain to miss that deadline. Mayor Zohran Mamdani, a Democrat and vocal proponent of closing Rikers, says construction delays and the need to further reduce the jail population make 2027 unachievable.
How it unfolded
- 2017A blue ribbon commission led by Judge Jonathan Lippman found no humane option other than to shutter the Rikers jails and build new borough jails.
- 2019The New York City Council voted to close Rikers and replace it with newer borough jails by 2027, with lawmakers invoking former prisoners who died, including Kalief Browder.
- Feb 2023Marvin Pines, 65, died at North Infirmary Command after a seizure; a state review found staff failed to meet minimum supervision standards and jail medical staff skipped basic assessments.
- Apr 2023A fire at North Infirmary Command prompted a Board of Correction investigation that produced a dozen recommendations for the department.
- Apr 2026The administration opened the long-delayed Bellevue Outposted Therapeutic Housing Unit, a secure ward at Bellevue Hospital for incarcerated people to access medical care.
- Jun 2026The city permanently closed a Rikers facility, transferring it from the Department of Correction to DCAS; North Infirmary Command closed and some detainees moved to the new Bellevue unit.
- Nov 18, 2026The city's jail population stood at 6,651, down from roughly 7,000 during the Adams administration.
- Nov 20, 2026Mayor Mamdani announced a plan to close Rikers by 2032, a five-year extension from Aug. 31, 2027.
- 2027North Infirmary Command, which opened in 1932, is slated to be torn down.
Key terms
- City Council
- The lawmaking body of New York City, made up of 51 members elected from districts across the five boroughs.
- pretrial detention
- Holding an arrested and charged person in custody until their trial.
- Board of Correction
- A New York City government agency that regulates conditions of confinement, correctional health, and mental health care in city jails.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Official
- Mayor Mamdani says the city has a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers and that his administration can be the first to deliver on it.
- Official
- Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards says unnecessary pretrial detention can increase eviction, job loss and rearrest, while case delay harms victims.
- Support
- City Council Speaker Julie Menin says delays under previous administrations show more time is needed to fulfill the 2019 commitment.
- Caution
- Critics at the time of the 2019 vote argued that shrinking the jail population to accommodate closure would mean more violent criminals on city streets.
Still unverified
It is unclear what the blueprint includes to speed up processing of criminal cases; some delays are tied to mental health evaluations, dragged-out court cases and a backlogged legal system. The city has not explained why North Infirmary Command was chosen as the first building to come down or which other facilities might be next.