COP31 declared failure over fossil fuel omission
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
A COP31 draft in Antalya stripped references to transitioning away from coal, oil and gas, pushing talks past Friday's close.
Panama threatens to block any deal without an oil cap, so one objection could sink the text.
Background
COP31 is the annual UN climate summit, this year held in Antalya, Turkey, with nearly 200 countries negotiating warming and financial aid for the poorest nations. At COP28 in Dubai in 2023, nations agreed for the first time to transition away from oil, gas and coal without targets or timelines, and the COP30 outcome in Belém, Brazil, last year did not mention fossil fuels at all. The summit is meeting amid rising living costs, an intensifying "super" El Nino, and a US-Israeli war with Iran whose Strait of Hormuz crisis disrupted roughly a fifth of global oil and LNG trade. It is also the first conference held with UN acknowledgement that keeping warming under 1.5C is no longer realistic.
How it unfolded
- 2023At COP28 in Dubai, nearly 200 countries agreed for the first time to transition away from oil, gas and coal, without targets or timelines.
- 2025The COP30 outcome in Belém, Brazil, did not mention fossil fuels at all, prompting some countries to pursue exits from coal, oil and gas outside the UN process.
- Nov 9, 2026Delegations from nearly 200 countries began meeting in Antalya, Turkey for COP31 to negotiate tackling global warming and financial aid to the poorest nations.
- Nov 16, 2026The COP31 presidency released an 18-page, 144-paragraph first draft calling for "the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems" and an accelerated phase-out.
- Nov 17, 2026The EU endorsed Türkiye's "35 by 35" electrification pledge.
- Nov 19, 2026A second draft by co-host Australia cut to nine pages stripped out two references to a transition away from coal, oil and gas and a call for an accelerated phase-out; Panama said it would block any deal without an oil production cap and methane steps.
- Nov 20, 2026COP31 entered its scheduled final day divided over a draft that does not mention fossil fuels, then went into overtime past 1500 GMT; the presidency reported 21 unresolved issues and Panama said it would "formally object" without climate finance, an oil cap and acknowledgement of failing goals.
- Nov 21, 2026A third promised revision was expected Saturday.
Key terms
- COP31
- The 31st yearly meeting of parties to the UN climate treaty, where governments assess and negotiate climate action.
- phase-out
- A gradual elimination of fossil fuel use, including vehicles and power plants, to cut emissions.
- El Nino
- The cooling phase of the El Niño–Southern Oscillation, marked by below-normal sea surface temperatures in the tropical Pacific.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Party
- Panama's Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro said countries are "being held hostage by the petroleum mafia" and that a cover document not mentioning fossil fuels is unacceptable.
- Expert
- Harjeet Singh of India's Satat Sampada Climate Foundation called the summit a "COP of betrayal and a COP of distraction," saying the second draft trims accountability while leaving lofty rhetoric.
- Caution
- COP31 President Murat Kurum, Turkey's Environment Minister, said he does not think they are taking a step back, that the text is not final, and that they are not there to discuss decisions at previous COPs.
- Official
- Australia's Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen, chairing negotiations, said the aim is "the most ambitious outcome that consensus will allow" and talks will continue until consensus is clear.
- Official
- An anonymous EU official said the draft is "not acceptable and not ambitious enough," adding "We don't want this COP to become a 'fossil' COP."
- Analysts
- Mohamed Adow of Power Shift Africa said the text had "gone backwards" and warned the summit risks being the "worst COP ever."
Still unverified
The latest text is expected to face further revisions before adoption, and decisions need approval from all countries, so a single objection can scupper a deal; Murat Kurum said the text was not final. Delegates in the halls Friday evening reportedly had little hope a third revision Saturday would revive any mention of fossil fuels.