UNC center Cameron Fens sues NCAA, wins temporary eligibility order
Archived — this story has rotated out of today’s deck. It is kept here in full.
The gist
UNC center Cameron Fens sued the NCAA and a judge granted a temporary restraining order on Nov 19.
The ruling lets the 7-footer play while his eligibility fight continues.
Background
Cameron Fens is a 7'0", 255-pound center at North Carolina who played two years at Illinois-Chicago and two at South Dakota, averaging 14.4 points and 8.7 rebounds last season for the Coyotes. He broke his right foot in South Dakota's seventh game of the 2024-25 season; his attorneys say staff treated it as a soft-tissue injury without an X-ray, and he kept playing until the fracture gave way about eight weeks later. Seeking a fifth year of eligibility, he first pursued a hardship waiver through South Dakota and was part of the Washington v. NCAA case in Tennessee before filing his own suit in Orange County, North Carolina — described as a local venue about 20 minutes from Chapel Hill and his final effort to gain eligibility for the 2026 season.
How it unfolded
- Nov 22, 2024Fens breaks his right foot in South Dakota's seventh game; per his attorneys, medical staff treated it as a soft-tissue injury and did not X-ray it.
- Jan 16, 2025After Fens plays on the foot for about eight weeks, the fracture gives way; a surgeon later finds partial healing from a lingering fracture and calls the second injury a progression of the first.
- Feb 2026Fens seeks a hardship waiver through South Dakota with the NCAA.
- Jul 31, 2026Fens is one of 19 student-athletes granted a temporary injunction in the Washington v. NCAA case in Tennessee.
- Oct 20, 2026The NCAA denies the waiver, saying Fens was medically cleared to compete at his original school.
- Nov 6, 2026A court order granting Fens a voluntary dismissal without prejudice in the Tennessee case is returned.
- Nov 9, 2026South Dakota appeals the waiver denial.
- Nov 18, 2026Fens files a lawsuit and seeks a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction against the NCAA in Orange County Superior Court in Hillsborough, NC.
- Nov 19, 2026Judge Alyson Grine grants the TRO, putting Fens on the court for now; the matter enters an appeal process. 247Sports reports he was granted a fifth year of eligibility.
- Nov 20, 2026The NCAA tells South Dakota it expects a decision on the appeal by Nov 20, the same day UNC hosts Marshall.
Key terms
- NCAA
- The rules determining whether a student athlete may compete in NCAA college sports.
- temporary restraining order
- A court order requiring a party to do or stop doing a specific act.
- redshirt waiver
- A delay of a college athlete's participation to extend their period of eligibility.
Source: Wikipedia
Who’s saying what
- Party
- Fens's attorneys argue the foot injury was misdiagnosed without imaging, that a correct diagnosis would have cut his season short enough to qualify for a redshirt waiver, and that amended NCAA Bylaw 12.6 makes him eligible by its own terms.
- Official
- The NCAA denied the waiver in October, saying Fens was medically cleared to compete at his original school, and did not immediately respond to comment requests from AP and WRAL.
- Support
- UNC coach Michael Malone said in a court affidavit that Fens is physical, strong and skilled, and would be a regular part of the rotation if eligible.
Still unverified
The misdiagnosis claim has been appealed to the NCAA and still awaits resolution, with the NCAA promising an answer by the next day. The TRO enters an appeal process in which the appeals court could find Judge Grine ruled in error and remove it, leaving Fens ineligible again. The case filing seems to suggest Fens, his lawyers and UNC do not feel the NCAA has necessarily been approaching the appeal in good faith.